religion report and need the explanation and answer to help me learn.
Theo-200 Alternate Assignment for Week 12
Prompt: Please provide annotations/reading notes for Martin Luther’s treatise “On the Freedom of a Christian”. This should include highlighting, summarizing, and analyzing key passages and quotes; underlining and explaining thesis statements from each main heading; looking up definitions for phrases that are not understood by the reader; and providing a list of questions that arise from the reader’s understanding of the treatise. Ultimately, this should be a more advanced summary paper of the assigned work that will generate discussion when we reconvene class. The purpose here is to gain a coherent grasp of the treatise via annotation.
Submission Date: 11:59 PM on Monday, November 13th via BlackBoard or email.
Learning Goal: Extensive and active engagement with Lutheran theology via a distinct exemplar of his work based in the historical socio-political and religious context of his time.
The reading is attached below.
Requirements: in directions
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.4LUTHERÕS EPISTLE TO LEO X, SUPREME PONTIFF 1JESUS.2MARTIN LUTHER sends greetings to Leo X, Roman Pontiff, in Christ Jesus our Lord. Amen. Surrounded by the monsters of this age, with which I have struggled and battled for three years, I am compelled at times to look to you and to think of you, Leo, most blessed father. Indeed, since you are widely held to be the sole cause of my battles, I cannot but think of you. And although the godless ßatterers around you, who rage against me without cause, forced me to appeal from your see to a future Council (given that I have no respect for the completely vain decrees of your predecessors, Pius and Julius, who with foolish tyranny pro-hibited such appeals), nevertheless, throughout this time I have never turned my soul away from Your Holiness so as neither to desire with all my powers the very best for you and for your see nor, as far as was in me, to seek the same with earnest and heartfelt prayers to God. I nearly started to despise and declare victory over those who up to now have tried to frighten me with the majesty of your authority and name, except I see that there remains one thing which I cannot despise and which has been the reason for my writing to Your Holiness for a second time.3 That is, I realize that I am accused of impertinence, now twisted into my great-est vice, because I am judged to have attacked your person.[Part One: LutherÕs Defense]However, so that I may confess this matter openly, whenever your person has been men-tioned, I am aware of having only said the greatest and best things. But if I had done oth-erwise, I could under no circumstances condone it; I would vote in favor of their judgment against me every time, and I would recant nothing more freely than this my impertinence and godlessness. I have called you a Daniel in Babylon, and every one of my readers knows fully well how, with extraordinary zeal, I have defended your remarkable innocence against your deÞler, Sylvester [Prierias]. Your reputation and the fame of your blameless life, chanted in the writings of so many men the world over, are too well known and digniÞed to be possi-bly assailed in any way by anyone, no matter how great. Nor am I so foolish to attack some-one whom absolutely everyone praises. As a matter of fact, I have even tried and will always try not to attack even those whom public opinion dishonors. For I take pleasure in no oneÕs faults, since I myself am conscious enough of the log in my own eye.4 Nor do I want to be the Þrst who throws a stone at the adulteress.51 This translation is a revision of Martin Luther, ÒFreedom of a Christian,Ó Luther Study Edition, trans. Mark Tranvik (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2008), itself a revision of the version in LutherÕs Works 31:327Ð77, Þrst translated by W. A. Lambert and Harold J. Grimm. The present revision of the text by Tim Wengert is based primarily on Weimar Ausgabe 7:38Ð73, but also using the more recent version with extensive notes, ed. Hans-Ulrich Delius, in MLStA 2:260Ð309. The headings, except where noted, are translated from the Basel edition of 1521, printed by Adam Petri (1454Ð1527).2 Following a monastic tradition, Luther began many of his early writings and letters with this word.3 The Þrst time was the preface to the Explanations of the Ninety-Five Theses of 1518. See WA 1:527Ð29.4 Matt. 7:3.5 John 8:1-11.[ 1 ][ 2 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.5Now, generally I have sharply attacked ungodly teachings, and I have been quick to snap at my opponents not because of their bad morals but because of their godlessness. I do not repent of this in the least, as I have resolved in my soul, despite the contempt of others, to per-sist in this fervent zeal, following the example of Christ, who in his zeal called his adversaries Òa brood of vipers,Ó Òblind,Ó Òhypocrites,Ó and Òchildren of the devil.Ó 6 And Paul branded the Magician [Elymas] a Òson of the devil . . . full of deceit and villainy.Ó 7 Others he ridiculed as Òdogs,Ó Òdeceivers,Ó and Òadulterators.Ó 8 If you consider any sensitive audience, no one will seem more biting and unrestrained than Paul. What is more biting than the prophets? The mad multitude of ßatterers imitates the ever so sensitive ears of our rational age, so that, as soon as we sense disapproval of our ideas, we cry that we are bitten. As long as we can rebuff the truth by labeling it something else, we ßee from it under the pretext of its being snappish, impatient, and unrestrained. What good is salt if it has lost its bite?9 What use is the edge of a sword if it does not cut? ÒAccursed is the one who does the LordÕs work deceitfully.Ó 10 For this reason, most excellent Leo, I beg you to admit that this letter vindicates me. And I beg you to convince yourself that I have never thought ill of your person and, moreover, that I am the kind of person who eternally wishes the very best things happen to you and that for me this strife is not with any person over morals but over the Word of truth alone. In every-thing else I will yield to anyone. I cannot and will not yield or deny the Word. If a person has thought something else about me or otherwise interpreted my positions, then that one is not thinking straight nor interpreting my true positions.However, I have rightly cursed your see, called the Roman Curia, which neither you nor any human being can deny is more corrupt than Babylon or Sodom and, as far as I can tell, is composed of depraved, desperate, and notorious godlessness. And I have made known that, under your name and under the cover of the Roman Church, the people of Christ are being undeservedly deceived. Indeed, I have thus resisted and will continue to resist [the Curia], as long as the Spirit of faith lives in meÑnot that I would strive for the impossible or that I would hope that, given the furious opposition of so many ßatterers, my works alone would improve anything in that chaotic Babylon, but I do acknowledge the debt owed to my fellow Christians,11 whom I must warn so that fewer may perish or at least have milder symptoms from that Roman plague. Indeed, as you yourself know, for many years nothing else has been ßooding the world from Rome than the devastation of possessions, bodies, and souls, and the worst examples of the worst possible things. All this is clearer than day to everyone. Moreover, out of the Roman Church, once the holiest of all, has been fashioned a completely licentious den of thieves, the most shameless of all brothels, the kingdom of sin, death, and hell, so that were the Antichrist to come, he could hardly think of anything that would add to its wickedness.In the meantime, you, Leo, sit as a lamb in the midst of wolves, as Daniel in the midst of lions, and you dwell with Ezekiel among the scorpions.12 How can you alone oppose these monsters? Add three or four of your best and most learned cardinals! ÒWhat are they among so many?Ó 13 Before you had even begun setting up the remedy, you would have all been poi-6 See Matt. 23:33, 13, 17; and John 8:44, respectively.7 Acts 13:10.8 Phil. 3:2; 2 Cor. 11:13; 2:17 (following the Latin; NRSV: ÒpeddlersÓ).9 Classical Latin authors often compared salt (especial Òblack saltÓ) with sharpness (e.g., Pliny [the Elder] (23Ð79), Historia naturalis, 10, 72, 93, par. 198) and sarcasm (e.g., Catullus [c. 84-54 BCE], 13, 5). See also Matt. 5:13.10 Jer. 48:10 (Vulgate).11 Literally, Òbrothers.Ó12 Matt. 10:16; Dan. 6:16; and Ezek. 2:6, respectively.13 See John 6:9.[ 3 ][ 4 ][ 5 ][ 6 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.6soned to death. It is all over for the Roman Curia. The wrath of God has fallen upon it com-pletely. It hates councils; it fears being reformed; it cannot allay its raging godlessness; and it fulÞlls the eulogy written for its Òmother,Ó about whom is said, ÒWe tried to heal Babylon, but she has not been healed. Let us forsake her.Ó 14 To be sure, it was part of your ofÞce and that of your cardinals to heal these ills, but Òthis gout derided the physicianÕs hands,Ó and neither horse Ònor chariot responds to the reins.Ó 15 Touched by deep affection, I have always been grieved, most excellent Leo, that you, who were worthy of far better times, became pope in this day and age. For the Roman Curia is not worthy of you or people like you but only Satan himself, who now actually rules in that Babylon more than you do.O that, having cast aside the glory that your completely accursed enemies heap upon you, you would instead live on the small income of a parish priest or on your familyÕs inheritance. Only the Iscariots, sons of perdition,16 are worthy of glorying in this kind of glory. For what are you accomplishing in the Curia, my Leo, except that the more wicked and accursed a per-son is, the more happily such a one uses your name and authority to destroy the wealth and souls of human beings, to increase wickedness, and to suppress faith and truth throughout the church of God? O truly most unhappy Leo, sitting on that most dangerous throneÑI am telling you the truth, because I wish you well! For if Bernard had compassion on Pope Eugenius, when the Holy SeeÑalthough already then very corruptÑstill governed with more hope [for improvement], why should we not complain about the three hundred years of cor-ruption and ruin that has been added since then? Is it not true that under the great expanse of heaven nothing is more corrupt, pestilential, and despicable than the Roman Curia? For it even surpasses by any measure the godlessness of the Turks, so that, truth be told, what was once the gate of heaven is now the very gaping mouth of hellÑsuch a mouth that because of the wrath of God cannot be blocked. This leaves only one option in these miseries: perhaps we can call back and rescue a few from this Roman abyss (as I said).Observe, my father Leo, my reason and design for raving against that pestilential see. For I completely avoided raging against your person because I even hoped that I would gain your favor and cause your rescueÑif I could have quickly and decisively broken open that prison of yours or, rather, your hell. For it would have been useful for your sake and your rescue, along with that of many others, had an attack by all talented, able people been able to mitigate some of the confusion in that godless Curia. Those who harm the Curia serve your ofÞce; those who by any and all means curse it glorify Christ. In short, Christians are those who are not ÒRomans.Ó[Part Two: A Narrative of LutherÕs Case]But, to enlarge upon this, attacking the Roman Curia or raising questions about it had never crossed my mind at all. For seeing that all remedies for saving it had failed, I had only con-tempt for it, served it divorce papers,17 and said to it, ÒLet the evildoer still do evil, and the Þlthy still be Þlthy.Ó 18 I devoted my time to the peaceful and quiet studies of Holy Scripture, by which I wanted to assist my brothers around me. When I made some progress in this, Satan opened his eyes and goaded his servant Johann Eck, a noted enemy of Christ, with an uncontrollable desire for glory. This resulted in Eck dragging me into an unexpected arena 14 Jer. 51:9 (Vulgate).15 Virgil (70Ð19 BCE), Georgics, 1, 514.16 The family of Judas Iscariot, as he was labeled in John 17:12.17 See Jer. 3:8.18 Rev. 22:11.[ 7 ][ 8 ][ 9 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.7for combat and trapping me on one little word that in passing I let slip concerning the pri-macy of the Roman Church. This glorious ÒThraso,Ó foaming at the mouth and gnashing his teeth, boasted that he would risk everything Òfor the glory of GodÓ and Òfor the honor of the Holy Apostolic See.Ó Puffed up with the prospect of abusing your power for himself, he expected nothing but certain victory, seeking not so much the primacy of Peter as his own preeminence among the theologians of this age. To achieve that goal, he imagined no small advantage in triumphing over Luther. When [the debate] ended unhappily for the Sophist, an incredible madness seized the man, for he sensed that whatever of the Roman shame had come to light through me was his fault alone.Therefore, most excellent Leo, allow me this once to make my case here and to accuse your true enemies. I believe you are aware what your legate, Cardinal St. Sisto, an unwise and unfortunateÑindeed, untrustworthyÑperson, had wanted [to do] with me. When out of rev-erence for your name I placed myself and the entire affair into his hands, he did not attempt to establish peaceÑwhich he could easily have done with one simple word, since at the time I had promised to be silent and make an end to my case if he commanded my adversaries to do likewise. Instead, as a man seeking glory, he was not content with this agreement and instead began to defend my adversaries, to allow them freedom [of speech] and to command me to recant, even though this was not part of his mandate at all. So, just when the case was in a very favorable place [for resolution], he came with his ill-natured tyranny and made it much worse. Thus, the blame for whatever followed this was not LutherÕs but totally CajetanÕs, who did not permit me to remain silent and quiet as I at the time had requested with all my might. What more could I have possibly done?Next followed Karl Miltitz, also a nuncio of Your Holiness. He traveled back and forth in various negotiations, omitting nothing in regards to restoring the caseÕs status quo, which Cajetan had rashly and arrogantly upset. Finally, with great difÞculty but assisted by the Most Illustrious Prince, Elector Frederick, he managed to speak with me several times pri-vately, where once again I yielded to your authority and was prepared to keep silent, even accepting as a judge [in the case] either the Archbishop of Trier or the Bishop of Naumburg. And thus it was settled and so ordered. While these good things were occurring and held the prospect [for success], behold, your other great enemy Eck19 madly rushed in with the Leipzig disputation, which he set up with Dr. Karlstadt. And when a new question arose concerning the primacy of the pope, he turned his concealed weapons on me and thoroughly destroyed the plans for peace. In the meantime, Karl Miltitz waited. The disputation was held, judges were chosen, and yet no decision was reached. Small wonder, given EckÕs lies, deceptions, and trickery, that everything everywhere was so completely stirred up, aggravated, and confused that, whatever the outcome of the decision, a greater conßagration would have ßared up. For he sought glory not truth. Here, too, I left nothing undone that I should have carried out.I concede that on this occasion much of Roman corruption came to light. But in this matter, whatever wrong was committed was EckÕs fault. He took on a task beyond his abili-ties. While striving furiously for his own glory, he revealed the shame of Rome to the whole world. This one is your enemy, my Leo, or rather, the enemy of your Curia. We can learn from his example that no enemy is more pernicious than a ßatterer.20 For what did his ßat-tery accomplish other than a kind of evil that not a single king would have been able to accomplish? For today the name ÒRoman CuriaÓ reeks the world over, and papal authority languishes. Its notorious ignorance is now despised.21 We would have heard nothing of this had Eck not upset the peace agreement between Karl and me. He himself senses this plainly 19 Luther is making a play on words: ÒEcce . . . EckÓ (Behold . . . Eck).20 See Cicero, De Amicitia, 91 (25).21 See, e.g., the reference to ÒRoman ignoranceÓ in Maurus Servius Honoratus (4thÐ5th century), Commentary on the Aeneid of Virgil, 8, 597. [ 10 ][ 11 ][ 12 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.8and, too late and to no avail, is offended by the subsequent publication of my books. He should have thought of this earlier, when, just like a bleating goat, he madly raved about his own glory and sought nothing but his own advantage with youÑat your great peril. That completely vain man hoped that I would stop and be silent out of fear for your name, since I do not believe that he supposed his own intelligence and learning would be enough. Now, because he realizes that I have conÞdence and continue to speak out, he understands albeit with overdue sorrow for his rash behaviorÑif he understands at allÑthat there is One in heaven who Òresists the proudÓ and humbles the presumptuous.22Therefore, after we had accomplished nothing by this disputation [in Leipzig] except greater confusion about the case in Rome, Karl von Miltitz came a third time, this time to the [Augustinian] fathers gathered for the chapter meeting of their order. He asked their advice about how to resolve the case, which was now greatly disturbing and dangerous. Since there was no hope of proceeding against me by force (thanks to GodÕs mercy!), some of their leaders were sent here to me. They requested that at least I show honor to the person of your Blessedness and in a humble letter plead that you and I are innocent. [They thought] that this matter was not yet completely hopeless as long as Leo X out of his innate goodness took a hand in it. Now, I have always offered and desired to keep the peace so that I might devote myself to quieter and more useful studies, since I have raged in this matter with such spirit in order that, by using great and forceful words and animus, I could restrain those whom I viewed as being no match for me at all. In this situation then, I not only freely yielded [to the delegation] but also accepted [the proposal] with joy and gratitude as a most welcomed kindness, provided that our hope could be realized.So, most Holy Father, I come and, even now, prostrate myself before you, begging, if possible, that you lay your hands on those ßatterers and enemies of peace (who only pretend to want peace) and rein them in. In turn, let no one presume, Most Holy Father, that I will recant, unless such a person wants to envelop this case in even greater turmoil. Furthermore, I will permit no binding laws for interpreting the Word of God, since Òthe Word of God must not be boundÓ because it teaches freedom in all other matters.23 Save for these two things, there is nothing that I could not or would not freely do or endure. I hate contentions. I will not provoke anyone at all. But, at the same time, I do not want to be provoked. But if I am pro-voked (with Christ as my teacher), I will not be at a loss for words. For, once this controversy has been brought before you and settled, Your Holiness could, with a short and simple word, command both parties to be silent and keep the peace, which is what I have always wanted to hear.[Peroration: Advice for Pope Leo]Consequently, My Father Leo, avoid listening to those sirens who turn you from being purely a human being into a demigod in order that you can command and decide whatever you wish. Do not let this happen; nor will you prevail in this way! You are a servant of servants and, more than all other human beings, in a most miserable and dangerous position. Do not let those deceive you who imagine that you are the lord of the world, who allow no one to be Christian outside of your authority and who babble on that you have power over heaven, hell, and purgatory. They are your enemies and seek to destroy your soul, as Isaiah says, ÒO my 22 See, e.g., 1 Pet. 5:5 and James 4:6.23 2 Tim. 2:9, an indirect reference to the tract, The Freedom of a Christian, to which this letter became attached.[ 13 ][ 14 ][ 15 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.9people, those who call you blessed deceive you.Ó 24 Those who place you above a council and the universal church err. Those who attribute to you alone the right to interpret Scripture err. For they seek to establish all manner of ungodliness in the Church under your name, and, alas, through them Satan has made great inroads among your predecessors.25 In sum, believe none of those who exalt you but only those who humble you. For this is the judgment of God, who Òhas brought down the powerful from their thrones and lifted up the lowly.Ó 26 Look at how different Christ is from his successors, although they still all want to be his vicars. And I fear that most of them have been too literally his Òvicars.Ó For a person is a vicar only in the absence of a superior. But if the pope rules when Christ is absent and not pres-ent and dwelling in his heart, what is that but to be a Vicar of Christ? And then, what is the church other than a whole group of people without Christ? Truly, what is such a vicar except an Antichrist and idol? How much more correctly did the apostles call themselves servants of a present Christ than vicars of an absent Christ!Perhaps I am presumptuous in attempting to teach such an exalted person, from whom all ought to be taught and (as your ÒplaguesÓ boast) from whom Òthe thrones of those who judgeÓ receive the [Þnal] decree. But I emulate Saint Bernard in his book On Consideration, addressed to Pope Eugenius, which every pope should commit to memory. I do this not from a desire to instruct you but from a sense of duty arising from pure and faithful solicitude that compels us to respect only the complete safety of our neighbors and that does not allow any consideration of their worthiness or unworthinessÑbeing focused only on their dangers and particular situations. For since I know that Your Holiness is twisted and tossed about in RomeÑthat is, driven by unending dangers and surrounded by the highest seasÑand that you are laboring on these things in miserable conditions such that you stand in need of even the smallest help from the least of the brothers, it did not seem foolish to me if for the moment I would forget your high majesty while fulÞlling the duty of love. I do not want to ßatter you in such a serious and dangerous situation. As far as that goes, if I am not under-stood to be your friend and most obedient servant, there is One who understands and judges.[Introduction to the Tract]In conclusion, so that I might not approach you, Holy Father, empty-handed, I offer this little tract, published under your name, in the prospect of an established peace and good hope. In it you can get a taste of the kinds of studies with which I could and would occupy myself far more fruitfully, if only your godless ßatterers permitted it now and before. It is a small thing with respect to its size, but (unless I am mistaken) it contains a summary of the whole Christian life, if you understand its meaning. Poor man that I am, I have nothing else to present to you. But then you do not need to be enriched by any other gift save a spiritual one. Therefore, I commend myself to your fatherly goodness. May the Lord Jesus preserve you forever! Amen. Wittenberg, September 6, 1520.24 Isa. 3:12 (Vulgate).25 See LutherÕs Address to the Christian Nobility (1520), TAL 1: 387Ð89.26 Luke 1:52.[ 16 ][ 17 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.10ON CHRISTIAN FREEDOMIntroduction27Many people view Christian faith as something easy, and quite a few people even count it as if it were related to the virtues. They do this because they have not judged faith in light of any experience, nor have they ever tasted its great power.28 [Faith Is Learned through Tribulations]29This is because a person who has not tasted its spirit in the midst of trials and misfortune cannot possibly write well about faith or understand what has been written about it. But one who has had even a small taste of faith can never write, speak, reßect, or hear enough about it. As Christ says in John 4[:14], it is a Òspring of water welling up to eternal life.ÓAlthough I cannot boast of my own abundance of faith and I also know quite well how short my own supply is, neverthelessÑgiven that I have been troubled by great and various trialsÑI hope I can attain to at least a drop of faith. And I hope that I can talk about faith in a way that, if not more elegant, is certainly clearer than has been done in the past by the fancy writers and the subtle disputants alike, who have not even under-stood their own writings.The Main Themes 30In order to point out an easier way for common folk31 (for I serve only them), I am proposing two themes concerning the freedom and servitude of the spirit.The Christian individual32 is a completely free lord of all, subject to none.The Christian individual is a completely dutiful servant33 of all, subject to all.Although these topics appear to contradict one another, nevertheless, if they can be found to be in agreement, they will serve our purposes beautifully. For both are from the Apostle Paul, when he says in 1 Cor. 9[:19], ÒFor though I am free with respect to all, I have made myself a slave to allÓ and in Rom. 13[:8], ÒOwe nothing to anyone except to love one another.Ó But ÒloveÓ by its very nature is dutiful and serves the one who is loved. The same was true of Christ who, although Lord of all, was nevertheless Òborn of a woman, born under the lawÓ 34 and who was at the same time free and slave, that is, at the same time Òin the form of GodÓ and Òin the form of a slave.Ó 3527 This sub-head is not in sixteenth-century editions of the tract.28 The same Latin word is translated here ÒvirtuesÓ or Òpower.Ó29 With few exceptions recorded in footnotes, all subtitles come from the second edition of the tract, printed in Basel by Adam Petri in 1521.30 The word ÒthemesÓ (themata) is a Greek loan word and a technical term in rhetoric and dialectics for the main topic or central proposition of a speech or an argument.31 Latin: rudes. This term can mean unlettered or uncultivated but here means the simple or common people, unfamiliar with the complexities of Scholastic theology. It is at this point that the German version begins. For further references to LutherÕs orientation toward the commoner, see his Treatise on Good Works.32 Latin here and in the next line: Christianus homo.33 Servus can be translated either servant or slave but here is rendered servant to correspond with LutherÕs German version (Knecht). In the Pauline letters, the NRSV translates the Greek doulos as ÒslaveÓ).34 An allusion to Gal. 4:4.35 An allusion to Phil. 2:6-7. [ 18 ][ 19 ][ 20 ][ 21 ][ 22 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.11Let us approach these two themes from a rather distant and unsophisticated starting point.36 Every human being consists of two natures: a spiritual and a bodily one. Accord-ing to the spiritual nature, which people label the soul, the human being is called a spiri-tual, inner, and new creature. According to the bodily nature, which people label the ßesh, a human being is called the ßeshly, outer, and old creature. Paul writes about this in 2 Cor. 4[:16], ÒEven though our outer nature is wasting away, our inner nature is being renewed day by day.Ó This distinction results in the fact that in the Scripture these contrary things are said about the same person, because these two Òhuman beingsÓ Þght against each other in the very same human being, as in Gal. 5[:17], ÒFor what the ßesh desires is opposed to the spirit, and what the spirit desires is opposed to the ßesh.Ó 37[The Spiritual, New, and Inner Person]38In looking at the inner person Þrst, we grasp how someone may become righteous,39 free, and truly Christian, that is, Òa spiritual, new, and inner person.Ó 40 What Christian Freedom Does Not Consist InIt is evident that no external thing at all, whatever its name, has any part in producing Chris-tian righteousness or freedom. Nor does it produce unrighteousness or servitude. This can be proven by a simple argument. How can it beneÞt the soul if the body is in good healthÑfree and active, eating and drinking and doing what it pleasesÑwhen even the most ungodly slaves to complete wickedness may overßow in such things? On the other hand, how could poor health or captivity or hunger or thirst or any other external misfortune harm the soul, when even the godliest, purest, and freest consciences are afßicted with such things? Not one of these things touches upon the freedom or servitude of the soul. Thus, it does not help the soul if the body wears the sacred robes set apart for priests or enters sacred places or per-forms sacred duties or prays, fasts, abstains from certain foods, or does absolutely any work connected with the body. Righteousness and freedom of the soul will require something completely different, since the things just mentioned could easily be done by some ungodly person and since such efforts result only in producing hypocrites. On the other side, the soul is not harmed if the body wears street clothes, goes around in secular places, eats and drinks like everyone else, does not pray aloud, and fails to do all the things mentioned above that hypocrites could do.The Word of God Is Necessary for the SoulMoreover, so that we may exclude everythingÑeven contemplation, meditation, and what-ever else can be done by the soulÕs effortsÑall of this has no beneÞt. One thing and one thing alone is necessary for the Christian life, righteousness, and freedom, and that is the most holy word of God, the Gospel of Christ. As John 11[:25] states: ÒI am the Resurrection and the Life, whoever believes in me will never die.Ó And John 8[:36]: ÒIf the Son makes you 36 Altior could mean distant, deeper, or ancient. Coupled with crassior, it seems to indicate either an old, crude example or one that seems far removed from the two stated themes.37 In the Greek and Latin texts of Galatians, the word ÒspiritÓ can also refer to the Holy Spirit.38 This subtitle was not in any sixteenth-century text. This begins the Þrst main section of the tract on the Þrst of the two themes introduced above.39 Except where noted, the Latin words iustus and iustitia will be translated ÒrighteousÓ and Òrighteousness,Ó not Òjustice,Ó which in current English usage denotes conformity to a legal principle.40 An allusion to the wording in the preceding paragraph.[ 23 ][ 24 ][ 25 ][ 26 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.12free, you will be free indeed.Ó And Matt. 4[:4]: ÒOne does not live by bread alone but by every word that comes from the mouth of God.Ó Therefore, we may consider it certain and Þrmly established, that the soul can lack everything except the word of God. Without it absolutely nothing else satisÞes the soul. But when soul has the word, it is rich and needs nothing else, because the word of God is the word of life, truth, light, peace, righteousness, salvation, joy, freedom, wisdom, power, grace, glory, and every imaginable blessing. David in Psalm 119 This is why the prophet throughout Psalm 119 and in so many other places [in the Psalter] yearns and sighs with groans and cries for the word of God.GodÕs Cruelest DisasterAgain, there is no crueler disaster arising from GodÕs wrath than when it sends Òa famine of the hearing of his word,Ó as stated in Amos 8[:11],41 just as there is no greater grace than whenever God sends forth his word, as in Ps. 107[:20]. ÒHe sent out his word and healed them and delivered them from their destruction.Ó And Christ was not sent into the world for any other ofÞce than the word. Moreover, the apostles, bishops and the entire order of clerics42 have been called and established only for the ministry of the word.What the Word of God IsYou may ask, ÒWhat is this word and how should it be used, when there are so many words of God?Ó I respond as follows. Paul explains what this word is in Rom. 1[:1, 3]: ÒThe gospel of God . . . concerning his Son,Ó who was made ßesh, suffered, rose, and was gloriÞed through the Spirit, the SanctiÞer.43 Thus, to preach Christ means to feed, justify, free, and save the soulÑprovided a person believes the preaching. For faith alone is the saving and efÞcacious use of the word of God. Rom. 10[:9] states: ÒIf you confess with your heart that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved,Ó and again [in v. 4]: ÒFor Christ is the end of the law, so that there may be righteousness for everyone who believes.Ó And Rom. 1[:17] states: ÒThe one who is righteous will live by faith.ÓFaith Alone JustiÞesFor the word of God cannot be received or honored by any works but by faith alone. There-fore, it is clear that the soul needs the word alone for life and righteousness, because if the soul could be justiÞed by anything else, it would not need the word and, consequently, would not need faith. Indeed, this faith absolutely cannot exist in connection with works, that is to say, in connection with any presumption of yours to be justiÞed at the same time by any works whatsoever. For this would be Òto limp in two different opinionsÓ to worship Baal44 and to Òkiss [my] hand,Ó which, as Job says, Òis a great iniquity.Ó 45 What Must Be BelievedTherefore, when you begin to believe, you discover at the same time that everything in you is completely blameworthy, damnable sins, as Rom. 3[:23] states: ÒAll have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.Ó And Rom. 3[:10-12] says, ÒThere is no one who is righteous,Ó no 41 LutherÕs citation of Amos is a paraphrase.42 Latin: ordo clericorum, that is, priests. Luther returns to this point later in the tract (p. 508f.).43 Paraphrasing Rom. 1:3-4. ÒSanctiÞcatorÓ here means the One who makes holy.44 An allusion to 1 Kgs. 18:21, ElijahÕs mocking of the priests of Baal.45 Job 31:27, which contrasts worship of God to worship of gold, nature, or the self.[ 27 ][ 28 ][ 29 ][ 30 ][ 31 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.13one does good, Òall have turned aside, altogether they have done worthless things.Ó 46 By this knowledge you will realize that you need Christ, who suffered and rose again for you, in order that, believing in him, you may become another human being by this faith, because all your sins are forgiven and you are justiÞed by anotherÕs merits, namely, by ChristÕs alone.A Human Being Is JustiÞed by No External WorkBecause this faith can only rule the inner person, as Rom. 10[:10] says (Òone believes with the heart and so is justiÞedÓ), and because this faith alone justiÞes, it is clear that the inner person cannot be justiÞed, freed, or saved by any external work or activity at all and that no works whatever have anything to do with the inner person. In the same way, on the other hand, the inner person becomes guilty and a condemned slave of sin only by ungodliness and unbelief of the heart and not by any external sin or work. It follows that the primary concern of each and every Christian ought to be that, by putting aside the supposition about works, they strengthen faith alone more and more and through that faith Ògrow . . . in knowl edgeÓ not of works but Òof Christ Jesus,Ó who suffered and rose again for them, as Peter in 2 Pet. 3[:18] teaches.47 For no other work makes a Christian. Thus, when the Jews in John 6[:28] asked what they should do to perform the works of God, Christ dismissed their multitude of works, which he realized puffed them up, and prescribed one work for them, saying, ÒThis is the work of God, that you believe in him whom he has sent,Ó for Òit is on him that God the Father has set his seal.Ó 48Faith Is an Incomparable TreasureTherefore, true faith in Christ is an incomparable treasure that includes with it com-plete salvation and protection from all evil, as it says in Mark 16[:16]: ÒThe one who believes and is baptized will be saved; but the one who does not believe will be con-demned.Ó Isaiah contemplated this treasure and foretold it in chapter 10[:23, 22]: ÒThe Lord will make an abbreviated and completed word upon earth,Ó and Òa completed abbreviation will overßow with righteousness.Ó 49 It is as if to say, ÒFaith, which is a compact and complete fulÞllment of the law, will Þll believers with such righteousness that they will need nothing else for righteousness.Ó So, too, Paul says in Rom. 10[:10]: ÒFor one believes with the heart and so is justiÞed.ÓScripture Contains Commands and Promises50You may be asking, however, how it comes about that faith alone justiÞes and how it confers so many great treasures without works, given that so many works, ceremonies, and laws are prescribed in the Scriptures. I answer this way. Before all else, remember what has been said above, namely, that faith alone without works justiÞes, frees, and saves. We shall make this clearer in a moment. In the meantime, it should be pointed out that the entire Scripture of God is divided into two parts: commands and promises. Commands, to be sure, teach what 46 Reading with the Vulgate.47 Literally: ÒIn the last chapter of 1 Peter,Ó leading most editors and translators to refer to 1 Peter 5:10. However, the preceding language comes from the last chapter of 2 Peter (3:18): ÒBut grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.Ó48 John 6:29, 27.49 Luther paraphrases v. 23 and then v. 22 of the Vulgate, adding the term Òword.Ó The Vulgate reads: ÒAn abbreviated completion will overßow with righteousness. For the Lord God will make a completion and an abbreviation of troubles in the midst of all the earth.Ó The NRSV states: ÒDestruction is decreed, overßowing with righteousness. For the Lord God of hosts will make a full end, as decreed, in all the earth.Ó Here Luther treats this text, which refers to a remnant of believing Israel that will survive AssyriaÕs destruction, allegorically.50 Luther introduced this theme earlier.[ 32 ][ 33 ][ 34 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.14is good, but what is taught is not thereby done. For the commands show what we ought to do but do not give the power to do it. They were instead established for this: so that they may reveal individuals to themselves. Through the commands they know their inability to do good, and they despair of their own powers. This explains why commands are called and indeed are the old testament.All Commands Are Equally Impossible for Us For example, Òyou shall not covetÓ 51 is a command that convicts us all of being sinners, because no one can avoid coveting, no matter how hard we might struggle against it. Thus, in order to keep this commandment and not covet, individuals are forced to despair of them-selves and to seek help elsewhere from someone else. As it says in Hos. [13:9]: ÒDestruction is your own, O Israel. Your help is only in me.Ó 52 However, what occurs with this single com-mandment occurs in the same way with them all. For all of them are equally impossible for us.The Law Must Be SatisÞedNow, when through the commands individuals have been made aware of their powerlessness and now become anxious about how to satisfy the law (since the law must be satisÞed so that Ònot one letter, not one stroke of a letter, will pass awayÓ 53Ñotherwise every person would be condemned without hope), they are then humbled and reduced to nothing in their own eyes. They Þnd nothing in themselves by which to be justiÞed and saved. At this point, the second part of Scripture (GodÕs promises, which announce GodÕs glory) arrives and says: ÒIf you want to fulÞll the law, ÔYou shall not covet,Õ as the law demands, then look here! Believe in Christ, in whom grace, righteousness, peace, freedom, and all things are promised to you. If you believe, you will have these things; if you do not believe, you will lack them.Ó We FulÞll Everything through FaithFor what is impossible for you to fulÞll using all the works of the law, which though great in number are useless, you will fulÞll easily and quickly through faith. Because God the Father has made all things depend on faith, whoever has faith has everything and whoever lacks faith has nothing. ÒFor God has imprisoned all in unbelief, so that he may be merciful to allÓ (Rom. 11[:32]).54 Thus, GodÕs promises give what the law demands, so that everything may belong to God alone, both the commands and their fulÞllment. God Alone Commands and FulÞllsGod alone commands, and God alone fulÞlls. Therefore the promises of God pertain to and, indeed, are the new testament.55The First Power of FaithNow since these promises of God are holy, true, righteous, peaceful, and Þlled with total goodness, what happens is this: The soul that adheres to them with a Þrm faith is not simply united with them but fully swallowed up by them, so that it not only shares in them but also 51 Exod. 20:17. 52 Luther cites the Vulgate, which mirrors the Greek and Syriac. Following the Hebrew, the NRSV has: ÒI will destroy you, O Israel; who can help you?Ó53 Matt. 5:18.54 Luther cites the Vulgate. NRSV has Òin disobedience.Ó55 Emphasis added. Luther equates Òold testament with any part of the Bible that commands something and Ònew testamentÓ for language that contains GodÕs promises.[ 35 ][ 36 ][ 37 ][ 38 ][ 39 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.15is saturated and intoxicated by their every power. For if ChristÕs touch healed, how much more will this tender touch in the spiritÑor, better, this ingestion by the wordÑcommuni-cate to the soul all things that belong to the word. Therefore, by this means, through faith alone without works, the word of God justiÞes the soul and makes it holy, true, peaceful, and free, Þlled with every blessing and truly made a child of God, just as John 1[:12] says: ÒTo all who . . . believe in his name, he gave power to become the children of God.ÓFrom these arguments it is easy to understand the source of faithÕs singular ability and why any good workÑor all of them put togetherÑcannot equal it at all. Why? Because no good work can cling to the word of God or even exist in the soul. Instead, faith alone and the word rule in it. For the word is of such a nature that the soul is formed by it. Just as heated iron glows like Þre because of its union with Þre, so it is clear that a Christian needs faith for everything and will have no need of works to be justiÞed. Now if works are unnecessary, then so is the law. If the law is unnecessary, then certainly such a person is free from the law. Moreover, it is true that Òthe law is not laid down for the righteous.Ó 56 So, this is the Chris-tian freedom referred to above, namely, our faith, which does not cause us to be lazy and lead evil lives but instead makes the law and works unnecessary for the righteousness and salvation of the Christian.The Second Power of FaithLet this sufÞce for the Þrst power of faith. Let us now look at the second. Faith functions also in the following way. It honors the one in whom it trusts57 with the most reverent and highest regard possible for this reason: Faith holds the one in whom it trusts to be truthful and deserving. The Highest HonorFor no honor is equal to attributing truthfulness and righteousness to someone, which is how we honor the one in whom we trust. Could we ascribe to anyone anything greater than truthfulness, righteousness, and absolutely perfect goodness? The Highest ContemptConversely, the greatest contempt is to suspect or to accuse someone publicly of being, in our opinion, a liar and wicked, which we do when we do not trust a person. So when the soul Þrmly believes the God who promises, it regards God as true and righteous. Nothing can show God greater respect! This is the highest worship of God: To bestow on God truth-fulness and righteousness and whatever else ought to be ascribed to the One in whom a person trusts. Here the soul submits itself to what God wishes; here it hallows GodÕs name and allows itself to be treated according to GodÕs good pleasure. This is because, clinging to GodÕs promises, the soul does not doubt that God is true, righteous, and wiseÑthe One who will do, arrange, and care for everything in the best possible way.56 1 Tim. 1:9, cited according to the Vulgate, which mirrors a literal translation of the Greek. NRSV has Òfor the innocent.Ó57 The phrase credere in (literally, Òto believe inÓ) in this paragraph is best rendered Òto trust.Ó See LutherÕs comments on the equivalent German phrase (glauben an) in his A Short Form of the Ten Commandments, Creed and LordÕs Prayer (1520), later printed in his Personal Prayer Book (1522) in LW 43:24: ÒThe second kind of faith means believing in GodÑnot just that I believe that what is said about God is true, but that I put my trust in him.Ó[ 40 ][ 41 ][ 42 ][ 43 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.16Perfect ObedienceIs not such a soul completely obedient to God in all things by this very faith? What com-mandment remains that such obedience has not completely fulÞlled? What fulÞllment is fuller than obedience in every situation?58 However, not works but faith alone offers this obedience.RebellionConversely, what greater rebellion against God, godlessness, and contempt of God is there than not to believe the One who promises? What is this but either to make God out a liar or to doubt that God is truthful? Or, to put it another way, is this not to ascribe truthfulness to oneself and falsehood and vanity to God? In so doing, is one not denying God and setting oneself up as an idol in oneÕs very heart? Of what good are works done in this state of god-lessness, even if they were angelic and apostolic works? Therefore, God rightly Òimprisons everything under unbelief,Ó not under anger or lust,59 so that people do not imagine that by chaste and gentle works of the law they fulÞll the law (granted that such things are civic and human virtues). Such people assume they will be saved, even though they are caught in the sin of unbelief and must thus either seek mercy or be justly condemned.God Honors Those Who Believe in HimBut when God sees that we ascribe truthfulness to him and by our heartÕs faith honor him as is his due, then in return God honors us, ascribing to us truthfulness and righteousness on account of this faith. For faith results in truthfulness and righteousness, giving to God his own. Thus, in return God gives glory to our righteousness. For it is true and righteous that God is true and righteous, and to ascribe this to God and to confess it means being true and righteous.60 As 1 Sam. 2[:30] states: ÒFor the ones who honor me I will honor, and those who despise me shall be treated with contempt.Ó As Paul says in Rom. 4[:3] that AbrahamÕs faith Òwas reckoned to him as righteousness,Ó because through it he fully gave God the glory. For the same reason, if we believe it will be reckoned to us as righteousness.The Third BeneÞt of Faith: Union with the Bridegroom 61The third incomparable beneÞt of faith is this: that it unites the soul with Christ, like a bride with a bridegroom. By this ÒmysteryÓ (as Paul teaches),62 Christ and the soul are made one ßesh. For if they are one ßesh and if a true marriageÑindeed by far the most perfect marriage of allÑis culminated between them (since human marriages are but weak shadows of this one), then it follows that they come to hold all things, good and bad, in common. Accord-ingly, the faithful soul can both assume as its own whatever Christ has and glory in it, and whatever is the soulÕs Christ claims for himself as his own.58 Luther plays on the words for ÒfulÞll,Ó ÒfulÞllment,Ó and ÒfullerÓ (impleverit, plenitudo, plenior).59 Referring to Rom. 11:32, cited above.60 Given the standard deÞnition of justice, iustus could be translated here ÒjustÓ rather than Òrighteous.Ó61 Combining consecutive marginal notes from the 2d ed. 62 Luther uses here the term sacramentum, found in the VulgateÕs translation of Eph. 5:32, applying what was said about the church to the soul. This translation of the Greek mysterion led eventually to the designation of certain rites in the church as sacraments (literally, in Latin, ÒoathsÓ or ÒvowsÓ but also ÒmysteriesÓ). First, in the 1522 German translation of the New Testament, Luther renders the phrase ÒsecretÓ (Geheimnis), in line with the Greek, while adding a marginal comment noting the Latin and Greek words.[ 44 ][ 45 ][ 46 ][ 47 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.17Consider These Invaluable Things!Let us examine these things in detail to see how invaluable they are. Christ is full of grace, life, and salvation; the soul is full of sins, death, and damnation. Now let faith intervene and it will turn out that sins, death, and hell are ChristÕs, but grace, life, and salvation are the soulÕs. For if he is the groom, then he should simultaneously both accept the things belong-ing to the bride and impart to the bride those things that are his. For the one who gives his body and his very self to her, how does he not give his all? And the one who receives the body of the bride, how does he not take all that is hers?63LoveÕs Duel in ChristThis is truly the most delightful drama, 64 involving not only communion but also a saving war, victory, salvation, and redemption. For Christ is God and a human being in one and the same person, who does not and cannot sin, die, or be damned; and his righteousness, life, and salvation are unconquerable, eternal, and all-powerful. When, I say, such a person shares in common and, indeed, takes as his own the sins, death, and hell of the bride on account of the wedding ring of faith, and when he regards them as if they were his own and as if he himself had sinnedÑsuffering, dying, and descending into hellÑthen, as he conquers them all and as sin, death, and hell cannot devour him, they are devoured by him in an astounding duel. For his righteousness is superior to all sins, his life more powerful than death, and his salvation more invincible than hell. The Wedding Ring of Faith for the Bride of ChristSo it happens that the faithful soul, through the wedding ring of its faith in Christ her bride-groom, is free from all sins, secure against death, protected from hell, and given the eternal righteousness, life, and salvation of her bridegroom, Christ. Thus, Òhe takes to himself a glorious bride without spot or wrinkle . . . making her clean by washing . . . in the word of life,Ó 65 that is, through faith in the word, life, righteousness, and salvation [of Christ]. As Hos. 2[:19] says, [the Lord] becomes engaged to her Òin faith, in mercy and compassion, in righteousness, and judgment.Ó 66The Majesty of the Wedding GarmentsWho can even begin to appreciate this royal marriage? What can comprehend the riches of this glorious grace? Here, this rich, upstanding bridegroom, Christ, marries this poor, dis-loyal little prostitute, redeems her from all her evil and adorns her with all his goodness. For now it is impossible for her sins to destroy her, because they have been laid upon Christ and devoured by him. In Christ, her bridegroom, she has her righteousness, which she can enjoy as her very own property. And with conÞdence she can set this righteousness over against all of her sins and in opposition to death and hell and can say, ÒSure, I have sinned, but my Christ, in whom I trust, has not sinned. All that is his is mine and all that is mine is his.Ó As it says in the Song of Sol. [2:16]: ÒMy beloved is mine, and I am his.Ó This is what Paul says in 1 Cor. 15[:57]: ÒThanks be to God, who gives us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ.Ó But this ÒvictoryÓ is over sin and death, as he notes in the previous verse [v. 56]: ÒThe sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is the law.Ó63 Here, among other things, Luther echoes the language of 1 Cor. 7:4.64 Latin: spectaculum, literally, Òa piece of theater.Ó65 A fairly close rendering of Eph. 5:27a and 26b, leaving out the words ÒchurchÓ and Òwater.Ó66 This citation matches the Vulgate: ÒAnd I will take you as my wife in righteousness and judgment and in mercy and in compassion, and I will take you as my wife in faith.Ó[ 48 ][ 49 ][ 50 ][ 51 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.18Why Ascribe These Things Only to Faith? 67From the preceding, you may once again understand why the fulÞllment of the law and justi-Þcation without any works by faith alone may only be ascribed to faith. You observe that the Þrst commandment, ÒYou shall worship one God,Ó is fulÞlled by faith alone.True Worship of GodFor even if you were nothing but good works from the soles of your feet to the top of your head, you would still not be righteous, worship God, or fulÞll the Þrst commandment, since God cannot be worshiped unless the glory of truth and of complete goodness is ascribed to him, as truly must be due him. Faith Does Works 68But works cannot do thisÑonly faith of the heart can. For not by working but by believ-ing do we glorify God and confess that God is truthful. On this basis, faith alone is the righteousness of a Christian and the fulÞlling of all the commandments, because the one who fulÞlls the Þrst commandment easily fulÞlls all the works of the others. Now works, being inanimate, cannot glorify God, although they can be done to GodÕs glory if faith is present. At this juncture, however, we are not asking about the kinds of works that are to be done but about the person who does them, who gloriÞes God and who produces works. This faith of the heart is the source and substance of all of our righteousness. Thus, it is a blind and dangerous instruction that teaches works must fulÞll the commandments, because the commandments must be fulÞlled before all works and thus works follow this fulÞllment, as we will hear.69The Prerogatives of the FirstbornIn order to examine more closely this grace that our inner person possesses in Christ, it must be realized that God in the Old Testament consecrated to himself all Þrstborn males. And this birthright was highly prized, giving power over all others with a double honor: priest-hood and kingship. The Þrstborn brother was a priest and ruler over all others. This Þgure foreshadowed Christ who, as the true and only Þrstborn of God the Father and of the Virgin Mary, was true king and priest but not according to the ßesh and this world. What ChristÕs Kingdom and Priesthood Consist In 70For his Òkingdom is not from this world.Ó 71 He rules over and consecrates heavenly and spir-itual things, such as righteousness, truth, wisdom, peace, and salvation. Not that everything on earth and in hell is not subjected to him (otherwise, how could he protect and save us from them?), but his kingdom does not consist in nor is it derived from such things. Simi-larly, his priesthood does not consist in the external pomp of robes and gestures, as did that human priesthood of Aaron then and as our ecclesiastical priesthood does today. But his consists in spiritual things, through which, in an invisible, heavenly ofÞce, he intercedes for us before God, offers himself there, and does all the things that a priest ought to do. 67 This section summarizes LutherÕs argument regarding the three powers of faith.68 This refers to the second power of faith.69 See the second major theme on p. 22 below.70 Combining two marginal glosses (2d ed.).71 John 18:36.[ 52 ][ 53 ][ 54 ][ 55 ][ 56 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.19The Priestly OfÞceThis is how Paul describes him in Hebrews [7], using the Þgure of Melchizedek.72 Not only does he pray and intercede for us, but he also teaches us inwardly in the spirit by the living instruction of his Spirit. These two things are properly speaking the ofÞces of a priest that are preÞgured by the visible prayers and sermons of human priests.How Faithful Christians Ought to Be Understood as Priests and Kings 73Now, just as Christ by his birthright possessed these two ranks, so he imparts them to and shares them with every believer legally in accord with the marriage described above, where whatever are the bridegroomÕs belong to the bride. Hence, all of us who trust in Christ are all priests and kings in Christ, as 1 Pet. 2[:9] states: ÒYou are a chosen race, an acquired people, a royal priesthood and a priestly kingdom, so that you may recount the powers of the one who called you from darkness into his marvelous light.Ó 74 The nature of these two ranks is as follows. The Spiritual Kingdom 75First, what pertains to kingship is this: through faith every Christian is exalted over all things and, by virtue of spiritual power, is absolutely lord of all things. Consequently, nothing at all can ever harm such a one to whom, indeed, all things are subject and forced to serve for salvation. Paul states this in Rom. 8[:28]: ÒWe know that all things work together for good for the elect.Ó 76 He says the same thing in 1 Cor. 3[:21b-23]: ÒAll things are yours, whether . . . life or death or the present or the future . . . and you belong to Christ.ÓNote!Now, this does not establish that Christians possess and exercise some sort of secular 77 power over everythingÑecclesiastical leaders far and wide are possessed by such madnessÑfor this is something that belongs to kings, princes, and human beings on earth.78 We see from our daily experience in life that we are subjected to all kinds of things, suffer many things, and even die. Indeed, the more Christian a person is, the more he or she is subject to evils, suffering, or death, as we see in Christ, the Þrstborn prince himself, and in all his holy brothers [and sisters]. This power, which Òrules in the midst of enemiesÓ 79 and is powerful Òin the midst of oppression,Ó 80 is spiritual. This is nothing other than Òpower made perfect in weaknessÓ so that in Òall things . . . I may gainÓ salvation.81 In this way, the cross and death are forced to serve me and to work together for salvation. This is a lofty, splendid high rank and a true, omnipotent power and a spiritual sovereignty, in which there is nothing so good or nothing so evil that cannot Òwork together for good,Ó 82 if only I believe. Still, because faith alone 72 Based upon Genesis 14 and Ps. 110:4. The authorship of Hebrews was contested in the sixteenth century, so that on other occasions Luther admitted that Paul did not write this letter.73 Combining two marginal glosses (2d ed.).74 Here Luther follows the Vulgate, replacing Òholy nationÓ with Òpriestly nationÓ and ÒannounceÓ with Òrecount.Ó Luther also uses this text in his Address to the Christian Nobility (p. 382).75 Mg. (2d ed.), moved slightly to correspond to the text.76 NRSV: Òfor those who love God.Ó Reference to the elect comes in the following verse.77 The word corporali, translated Òsecular,Ó is literally, ÒbodilyÓ or Òphysical.Ó78 Luther expanded this distinction in 1523 in On Secular Authority (LW 45:75Ð129).79 Ps. 110:2.80 An allusion to 2 Cor. 4:8 as rendered in ErasmusÕs Latin translation of the Greek.81 Allusions to 2 Cor. 12:9 and Phil. 3:9.82 Rom. 8:28.[ 57 ][ 58 ][ 59 ][ 60 ][ 61 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.20sufÞces for salvation, I do not need anything else except for faith exercising its power and sovereignty of freedom in these things. Look here! This is the immeasurable power and free-dom of Christians.We Are Priests Forever 83Not only are we the freest kings of all, but we are also priests forever. This is more excellent by far than kingship, because through the priesthood we are worthy to appear before God, to pray for others, and to teach one another the things that are of God. For these are the priestly duties that absolutely cannot be bestowed on anyone who does not believe. Christ obtained this priesthood for us, if we trust in him, so that as we are confreres, coheirs, corulers, so we are co-priests with him, daring to come with conÞdence into GodÕs presence in the spirit of faith and cry, ÒAbba, Father,Ó 84 to pray for another and to do all the things that we see are done and preÞgured by the visible and corporeal ofÞce of priests.Only Evil Comes to NonbelieversBut nothing serves persons who do not believe, nor does anything Òwork together for good.Ó 85 Instead, such individuals are slaves of all things and give themselves over to evil, because they use everything wickedly for their own advantage and not to the glory of God. Thus, they are not priests but profane people. Their prayers become sin, nor do they appear in GodÕs presence, because God does not listen to sinners. Who, therefore, can comprehend the height of this Christian rank, which through its regal power is lord of all thingsÑdeath, life, sin, and the likeÑbut through its priestly glory can do all things before God, because God does what the priest asks and desires? As it is written: ÒHe fulÞlls the desire of all who fear him; he also hears their cry, and saves them.Ó 86 A person certainly arrives at this glory not by works but by faith alone.The Freedom of ChristiansFrom the foregoing, anyone can clearly see how the Christian is free from all things and is over all things, so that such a person requires no works at all to be righteous or saved. Instead, faith alone bestows all these things in abundance. Now, if someone were so foolish as to presume to be made righteous, free, saved, and Christian through any good work, then such one would immediately lose faith along with all other good things. This foolishness is beautifully illustrated in that fable where a dog runs along a stream holding a piece of real meat in his mouth. When, deceived by the reßection of the meat in the water, the dog tries to get it by opening its mouth and loses both the meat and the reßection.[A Digression on the Meaning of Priesthood]At this point, you may ask, ÒIf all people in the church are priests, by what name do we distinguish those we now call priests from the laity?Ó I respond that an injustice has been done to these wordsÑÒpriest,Ó Òcleric,Ó Òa spiritual one,Ó and Òa churchmanÓÑwhen they are transferred from all other Christians to those few who now are called by this faulty usage Òchurchmen.Ó For Holy Scripture does not distinguish at all among them, except that it calls Òministers,Ó ÒservantsÓ and ÒstewardsÓ those who now are proudly labeled popes, bishops, and lords but who should be serving others with the ministry of the word in order to teach 83 Referring back to Ps. 110:4.84 Rom. 8:15.85 Rom. 8:28. Luther uses the singular (ÒaÓ person) throughout this paragraph.86 Ps. 145:19.[ 62 ][ 63 ][ 64 ][ 65 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.21the faith of Christ and the freedom of the faithful. For, although it is true that we are all equally priests, nevertheless we cannot all serve and teach nor, even if we can, ought we all to do so publicly. As Paul states in 1 Cor. 4[:1]: ÒLet a person regard us as servants of Christ and dispensers of GodÕs mysteries.Ó 87What the Ministry of Churchmen Has BecomeAgainst this, such ÒdispensingÓ has now turned into such a display of power and a terrible tyranny that no national or worldly political power can be compared to it. It is as if the laity were something other than Christians. As a result of this perversity, the knowledge of Chris-tian grace, faith, freedom, and Christ has perished entirely, only to be replaced by an intol-erable captivity to human works and laws. As the Lamentations of Jeremiah puts it, we have become slaves of the vilest possible people on earth, who abuse our misery in all baseness and degradation of their desire.88How Christ Must Be PreachedTo return to my main topic, I believe that it has become clear that it is not sufÞcient or even Christian if, as those who are the very best preachers today do, we only preach ChristÕs works, life, and words just as a kind of story or as historical exploits (which would be enough to know for an example of how to conduct our lives). Much worse is when there is complete silence about Christ and human laws, and the decrees of the fathers are taught instead of Christ. Moreover, some even preach Christ and recite stories about him for this purpose: to play on human emotions either to arouse sympathy for him or to incite anger against the Jews. This kind of thing is simply childish and womanish nonsense. Preaching, however, ought to serve this goal: that faith in Christ is promoted. Then he is not simply ÒChristÓ but ÒChrist for you and me,Ó and what we say about him and call him affect us. This faith is born and preserved by preaching why Christ came, what he brought and gave, and what are the needs and the fruit that his reception entail. This kind of preaching occurs where Christian freedom, which we gain from him and which makes us Christians all kings and priests, is rightly taught. In him we are lords of all, and we trust that whatever we might do is pleasing and acceptable in GodÕs sight, as we said above.The Fruit of the Best Preaching89What personÕs heart upon hearing these things would not rejoice from its very core and upon accepting such consolation would not melt90 in love with ChristÑsomething completely unattainable with laws and works? Who could possibly harm or frighten such a heart? If awareness of sin or dread of death overwhelms it, it is ready to hope in the Lord. It neither fears hearing about these evils nor is moved by them, until Þnally it despises its enemies.91 For it believes that ChristÕs righteousness is its own and that its sin is now not its own but ChristÕs. More than that, the presence92 of ChristÕs righteousness swallows up every sin. As noted above, this is a necessary consequence of faith in Christ. So the heart learns with the Apostle to scoff at death and sin and to say: ÒWhere, O death, is your victory? Where, O death, is your sting? The sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is the law. But thanks be 87 Reading with the Vulgate.88 Perhaps an allusion to Lamentations 1 or to the entire book.89 Luther moves from what preaching is to its effects.90 Literally, Òbecome sweet.Ó91 Perhaps an allusion to Ps. 110:1.92 Literally, Òface.Ó[ 66 ][ 67 ][ 68 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.22to God, who gives us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ.Ó 93 For death is swallowed up in victoryÑnot only ChristÕs but oursÑbecause through faith it becomes our victory and is in us and we are conquerors.Enough now has been said about the inner person, its freedom and its origin in the righ-teousness of faith. This inner person requires neither laws nor good works, which are harm-ful to it whenever someone presumes to be justiÞed through them.[The Outer Person] 94Let us now turn to the second part, which concerns the outer person. Here we will respond to all those people who are offended by the word of faith and what has been said about it. They say, ÒIf faith does all things and alone sufÞces for righteousness, why then are good works commanded? We will therefore be content with faith, take our ease and do no works.Ó I respond, ÒNot so, you wicked people, not so!Ó To be sure, this would be true if we were com-pletely and perfectly inner, spiritual persons, which will not happen until the resurrection of the dead on the last day. As long as we live in the ßesh, we are only beginning and advancing toward what will be perfected in the future life. The Apostle in Romans 8[:23] calls this the ÒÞrst fruits of the Spirit,Ó because in this life we will have received only a tenth but in the future life the fullness of the Spirit. So, this part of the essay pertains to what was said at the beginning: The Christian is a slave of all and subject to all. Insofar as a Christian is free, he or she does nothing; insofar as the Christian is a slave, he or she does all things. Now we shall see how this can happen.To be sure, as I have said, the inner person is in the spirit fully and completely justiÞed through faith. Such a one has what he or she ought to have, except of course that this very faith and its riches ought to increase day by day toward the future life. For now, however, this person remains in this mortal life on earth. In this life a personÕs own body must be ruled and be in relation with other human beings. Where Works Begin Now here is where works begin. Here is not the time for leisure; here care must be taken to train the body by means of fasting, vigils, and other labors and to subdue it by the spirit. In this way it may obey and be conformed to the inner person and faith, so that it may not rebel against or impede the inner person (as is its nature when not held in check). The Single Concern of the Inner PersonFor the inner personÑconformed to God and created in the image of God through faithÑis joyful and glad on account of Christ, in whom all good things have been conferred upon such a one. Because of this, that person has only one concern: to serve God joyfully, with boundless love and with no thought of earning anything. While acting this way, immedi-ately the inner creature offends a contrary will in its own ßesh, one that serves the world and tries seeking after what belongs to it. Because the spirit of faith cannot tolerate this at all, it attempts with joyful zeal to suppress and coerce the ßesh. As Paul says in Rom. 7[:22-23]: ÒI delight in the law of God according to my inner person,95 but I see in my members another 93 1 Cor. 15:55-57.94 Here begins the second main section of the tract. This subtitle was not in any sixteenth-century text. Instead, the marginal gloss in the second edition reads: ÒA question from those who do not understand LutherÑor ratherÑwhat faith is.Ó95 Reading with the Vulgate.[ 69 ][ 70 ][ 71 ][ 72 ][ 73 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.23law Þghting against the law of my mind and making me captive to the law of sin.Ó In another place,96 he writes, ÒI punish my body and enslave it, so that after proclaiming to others I myself should not be disqualiÞed.Ó And in Gal. 5[:24] he states, ÒAnd those who belong to Christ Jesus have cruciÞed the ßesh with its passions and desires.Ó Under What Supposition Are Works to Be Done?These works, however, ought not to be done under the supposition that through them a person is justiÞed before God. For faith, which alone is righteousness before God, does not endure this false opinion but supposes [that works be done] only so that Òthe body may be enslavedÓ and may be puriÞed from its evil Òpassions and desiresÓ so that the eye may not turn again to these expunged desires.97 Because the soul has been cleansed through faith and made to love God, at the same time it wants all things (in particular the body) to be cleansed, so that all things may love and praise God with it. As a result, the human creature cannot be idle because of the demands of its body, and, because of the body, it attempts to do many good things to bring it under control. Nevertheless, these works are not what justify someone before God. Instead, the person does them in compliance to God out of sponta-neous love, considering nothing else than the divine favor to which the person wishes to comply most dutifully in all things.How to Discipline the BodyFor this reason, all individuals98 can easily Þgure out for themselves the Òmeasure or discre-tionÓ (as people call it) 99 to which they ought to discipline their bodies. For they may only fast, perform vigils, and labor to the extent that they see it to be necessary for suppressing the bodyÕs wantonness and desire. Those who presume to be justiÞed by works, however, have no regard for extinguishing100 desires but only for the works themselves. They suppose that if they do so many great works, then they will fare well and be made righteousÑsometimes even injuring their minds and destroying or at least rendering useless what makes them human. Wanting to be justiÞed and saved through works without faith is simply monstrous foolishness and ignorance of the Christian life and faith!An Excellent AnalogySo that we may make it easier to understand what we have said, let us illustrate these things with some analogies. The works of Christian individuals,101 who are justiÞed and saved through their faith by the pure and gracious mercy of God, ought not be considered from any other perspective than would be the works of Adam and Eve and their children had they not sinned. This is talked about in Gen. 2[:15]: God Òplaced the man,Ó whom he had formed, Òin paradise . . . so that he might work and take care of it.Ó 102 Now, God created Adam to be righteous, upright, and without sin, so that through his work and care he had no need to be justiÞed or made upright. Rather, so that he would not become idle, the Lord gave him a job, namely, that he care for and watch over paradise. These were truly the freest works, done neither Òto make [a person] acceptable to anyoneÓ (except to divine favor) nor to obtain righteousness, which Adam already had fully and which would have been inborn in all of us.96 1 Cor. 9:27.97 Cf. 1 Cor. 9:27; Gal. 5:24; and 1 John 2:16.98 In the singular in the original.99 Latin: mensura aut discretio. This phrase is found in medieval books on virtues and vices and in medieval penitential manuals. 100 Latin: mortiÞcatio.101 Singular in the original text.102 Cited according to the Vulgate.[ 74 ][ 75 ][ 76 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.24Faith Puts a Person Back in ParadiseIt is the same way with works of believing individuals,103 who through their faith are once again put back in paradise and recreated from scratch. They would not do works to become or to be righteous but in order not to be idle and Òto work and watch overÓ their bodies. For them these works arise from the same freedom [as AdamÕs], done only in consideration of divine favorÑexcept that we are not yet fully recreated with perfect faith and love, which ought to increase not through works but through themselves.Another ComparisonHere is another analogy. When a consecrated bishop dedicates a church building, conÞrms children, or performs some other duty pertaining to his ofÞce, he is not consecrated into ofÞce by performing these very works. Far from it! Unless he had already been consecrated a bishop beforehand, all of these works would be worthless; they would instead be foolish, childish, and silly. So also individual Christians,104 who are consecrated by their faith, do good works, but through them they are not made holy 105 or Christian. For this arises from faith alone; indeed, unless they believed and were Christian beforehand, all of their works would be worthless and would be truly ungodly and damnable sins.Two Statements Worth RememberingTherefore, these two sayings are true: ÒGood works do not make a person good, but a good person does good works,Ó and ÒEvil106 works do not make a person evil, but an evil person does evil works.Ó Thus, a personÕs essence or character must be good before all works, and good works follow and proceed from a good person.A ComparisonAs Christ also says, ÒA good tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a bad tree bear good fruit.Ó 107 It is obvious that fruit do not bear a tree nor does a tree grow on fruit, but just the reverse: trees bear fruit and fruit grow on trees. Therefore, just as it is necessary that trees exist prior to their fruit and that fruit make trees neither good nor bad, but that, on the contrary, spe-ciÞc kinds of trees make speciÞc kinds of fruit, so it is necessary that Þrst the very character of a person be good or evil before doing any good or evil work and that a personÕs works do not make one evil or good but rather that a person does evil or good works.Another ComparisonSimilar things can be seen in construction. A good or bad house does not make a good or bad builder, but a good or bad builder makes a good or bad house. As a general rule, no work makes its kind of artisan, but an artisan makes a particular kind of work. This same reality obtains for the works of human beings. Whatever kind of person one isÑeither in faith or unbeliefÑthat determines oneÕs work: good if done in faith, evil if done in unbelief. But this may not be reversed: as if whatever the kind of work determines the kind of human beingÑeither in faith or unbelief. For just as works do not make someone a believer, so also they do not make a person righteous. On the contrary, just as faith makes someone a believer and righteous, so also it produces good works.103 In the singular throughout this paragraph in the original.104 In the singular throughout this paragraph in the original text.105 The same adjective translated ÒconsecratedÓ above.106 In these paragraphs the Latin malum is translated either ÒevilÓ or Òbad,Ó depending on the context.107 Matt. 7:18.[ 77 ][ 78 ][ 79 ][ 80 ][ 81 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.25Faith Alone JustiÞesSince, therefore, works do not justify anyone and a person must be righteous before doing something good, these things are absolutely clear: that faith aloneÑbecause of the sheer mercy of God through Christ [given] in his wordÑproperly and completely justiÞes and saves a person; and that no law is necessary for a ChristianÕs salvation, since through faith one is free from every law and does everything that is done spontaneously, out of sheer freedom. Such a person seeks nothing for a payment or for salvationÑalready being satisÞed and saved by GodÕs grace from oneÕs faithÑbut seeks only what pleases God.Unbelievers Do Not Become Evil by WorksIn the same way, no good work of an unbeliever contributes toward righteousness or salva-tion. On the other side, no evil work makes an unbeliever evil or damnable. Instead, unbelief, which makes an evil person and tree, does evil and damnable works. Thus, when someone is good or evil, this arises not from works but from faith or unbelief, as Sir. [10:14] says, ÒThis is the beginning of sin, that a person falls away from God,Ó that is, Òdoes not believe.Ó Paul states in Hebrews 11[:6]: ÒFor whoever would approach God must believe.Ó And Christ says the same thing: ÒEither make the tree good, and its fruit good; or make the tree bad and its fruit bad,Ó 108 as if he were saying, ÒLet whoever wants to have good fruit begin with the tree and plant a good one.Ó Therefore, let whoever wants to do good things begin not with the doing but with the believing. For only faith makes a person good, and only unbelief makes someone evil.Works Make a Human Being Good but Only in Human EyesTo be sure, it is true that in the eyes of other human beings, works make a human being good or evil. But this happens the same way as when it is known or shown that someone is good or evil, as Christ says in Matt. 7[:20], ÒYou will know them by their fruits.Ó But all of this remains external and on the surface, which is just where many who presume to write and teach about Òthe good works by which we are justiÞedÓ are led astray. The Source of Some PeoplesÕ ErrorMeanwhile, they do not even mention faith: going their false ways,109 always leading astray, Òprogressing from bad to worse,Ó 110 Òthe blind leading the blind,Ó 111 wearying themselves with many works and still never arriving at the true righteousness. Paul speaks about these people in 2 Tim. 3[:5, 7]: ÒHolding to the outward form of godliness but denying its power . . . who are always being instructed and can never arrive at knowledge of the truth.ÓTherefore, whoever does not want to fall into the same error with these blind people must look beyond works, laws, and teachings about works. More than that, one must focus on the person completely apart from works and on how such a one is justiÞed. A person is justiÞed and saved not by works or laws but by the Word of God (that is, by the promise of GodÕs grace) and by faith. In this way, what remains Þrm is the glory of the divine majesty, which saves us who believe not by works of righteousness that we do but in accord with GodÕs mercy through the word of his grace.108 Matt. 12:23.109 Echoing biblical condemnations, as in 2 Kgs. 8:18.110 Paraphrasing 2 Tim. 3:13.111 Matt. 15:14.[ 82 ][ 83 ][ 84 ][ 85 ][ 86 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.26Rules for Understanding the Teachings of Many People TodayFrom all that has been said, it is easy to understand on what grounds good works must be rejected or accepted and by what rule everyoneÕs current teachings about good works must be evaluated. For if works are coupled with righteousness and by that perverse Leviathan 112 and false persuasion take on such a character that you presume to be justiÞed through them, then they become absolutely compulsory and extinguish freedom along with faith. By this kind of linkage, such works are no longer good but instead truly damnable. For they are not free, and they blaspheme against the grace of God, to whom alone belong justiÞcation and salvation through faith. What works are powerless to guarantee, they nevertheless pretend to do by this godless presumption and through this foolishness of ours, and thereby they intrude violently into the function of grace and its glory.The Basis of LutherÕs Teaching 113Therefore, we do not reject good works. On the contrary, we highly cherish and teach them. For we do not condemn them for their own sake but on account of this godless linkage and perverse opinion that try to seek righteousness [through them]. This makes them appear good on the surface when in reality they are not good. By such works people are deceived and, like ravenous wolves in sheepÕs clothing, they deceive [others].114The Work of LeviathanBut this Leviathan and perverse opinion about works is impossible to overcome where gen-uine faith is lacking. These Òwork-saintsÓ cannot get rid of this [monster] unless faith, its destroyer, comes and rules in the heart. Nature by itself cannot drive it out and, worse yet, cannot even recognize it but rather considers it the ground for the holiest of desires. In this situation, if (as godless teachers have done) custom invokes and strengthens this depravity of nature, it becomes an incurable evil that seduces and destroys countless people irrepara-bly. Thus, while it is Þne to preach and write about penitence, confession, and satisfaction, nevertheless, they are without a doubt deceptive and diabolical teachings when placed here [with works] and not derived from faith as taught above. For this is why Christ, like John [the Baptist], did not only say, ÒRepent,Ó 115 but added the word of faith, saying: ÒThe kingdom of heaven has come near.Ó 116Faith Ought to Be Awakened in PreachingFor we must preach not only one word of God but both, Òbringing forth new and old from the treasureÓ 117Ñboth the voice of the law and the word of grace. The voice of the law ought to be Òbrought forthÓ so that people may be terriÞed and led to a knowledge of their sins and thereby directed toward repentance118 and a better basis for life. But the word must not stop here. For this would be only Òto woundÓ and not Òto bind upÓ; Òto strike downÓ and not Òto healÓ; Òto killÓ and not Òto make aliveÓ; Òto lead into hellÓ and not Òto lead outÓ; Òto humbleÓ 112 See Job 41; Isa. 27:1; Pss. 74:14; 104:26; and Job 3:8. 113 The second of several marginal glosses from the second edition referring to Luther in the third person. See above, p. 22, note 94.114 See Matt. 7:15.115 In the Latin Vulgate, the text (poenitentiam agite) may be translated either ÒDo penanceÓ or ÒRepent.Ó116 Matt. 4:17.117 Matt. 13:52. In contrast, medieval commentators interpreted Òold and newÓ as the Old and New Testaments.118 Latin: poenitentia, a word that may be translated as Òrepentance,Ó Òpenitence,Ó or the Òsacrament of penance.Ó[ 87 ][ 88 ][ 89 ][ 90 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.27but not Òto exalt.Ó 119 Therefore, the word of grace and promised forgiveness ought also to be preached in order to instruct and awaken faith. Without this other word [of grace], law, contrition, penitence, and everything else are done and taught in vain.The Origin of Repentance and FaithTo be sure, preachers of repentance and grace are still around, but they do not explain GodÕs law and promise in light of their purpose and spirit, so that people can Þnd out where repen-tance and grace come from. For repentance arises from GodÕs law, but faith or grace come from the promise of God, as Rom. 10[:17] states: ÒSo faith comes from what is heard, and what is heard comes through the word of Christ.Ó It happens like this: A person, who has been humbled by the threats and fear of the divine law and led to self-knowledge, is consoled and raised up through faith in the divine promise. As Psalm 30[:6] says, ÒWeeping may linger for the night, but joy comes with the morning.ÓConcerning Works for the NeighborUp to now we have spoken about works in general and, at the same time, about those speciÞc things that a Christian must do to train his or her own body. Finally, we will discuss those things done for oneÕs neighbor. For a human being does not live in this mortal body solely for himself or herself and work only on it but lives together with all other human beings on earth. Indeed, more to the point, each person lives only for others and not for himself or her-self. The purpose of putting the body in subjection is so that it can serve others more genu-inely and more freely. As Paul says in Rom. 14[:7-8], ÒWe do not live to ourselves. If we live, we live to the Lord, and if we die, we die to the Lord.Ó Thus, it can never happen that in this life a person is idle and without works toward oneÕs neighbors. For it is necessary to speak, act, and live with other human beings, just as Christ was Òmade in human likeness and found in human formÓ 120 and Òlived with humankind,Ó as Bar. 3[:37] says.Serving All PeopleNevertheless, no one needs even one of these works to attain righteousness and salvation. For this reason, in all of oneÕs works a person should in this context be shaped by and contem-plate this thought alone: to serve and beneÞt others in everything that may be done, having nothing else in view except the need and advantage of the neighbor. So the Apostle com-mands that Òwe work with our hands so that we may give to those in need.Ó 121 Although he could have said, Òso that we may support ourselves,Ó he said instead, Ògive to those in need.Ó Why the Body Must Be Taken Care OfFor, under these circumstances, it is also Christian to care for the body. At times when the body is healthy and Þt, we can work and save money and thereby can protect and support those who are in need. In this way, the stronger members may serve the weaker 122 and we may be sons [and daughters] of God: one person caring and working for another, Òbearing one anotherÕs burdens and so fulÞlling the law of Christ.Ó 123 Look here! This is truly the Chris-tian life; here truly Òfaith is effective through love.Ó That is, with joy and love [faith] reveals 119 A combination of Deut. 32:39; 1 Sam. 2:6-7; and Hos. 6:1.120 Phil. 2:7, according to the Latin Vulgate. 121 Luther here paraphrases the Latin Vulgate of Eph. 4:28. The Vulgate reads: ÒLet [the former thief] labor by working with his hands, which is a good thing, so that he may have a source from which he might contribute to the one who suffers need.Ó122 Luther was combining images from Rom. 14 and 1 Cor. 8Ð9, 12.123 Gal. 6:2.[ 91 ][ 92 ][ 93 ][ 94 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.28itself in work of freest servitude, as one person, abundantly Þlled with the completeness and richness of his or her own faith, serves another freely and willingly. The Christian LifeThus, after Paul had taught the Philippians how they were made rich through faith in Christ (in which faith they had obtained all things), he then teaches them by saying, ÒIf then there is any encouragement in Christ, any consolation from love, any sharing in the Spirit, any compassion and sympathy, make my joy complete: be of the same mind, having the same love, being in full accord and of one mind. Do nothing from selÞsh ambition or conceit but in humility regard others as better than yourselves. Let each of you look not to your own interests but to the interests of others.Ó124 Here we see clearly that the Apostle places the life of Christians into this framework,125 so that all of our works may be ordered toward the advantage of others. Since each and every person thus thrives through their own faithÑso that all other works and the sum total of life ßows out from that very faithÑby these works each may serve and beneÞt the neighbor with willing benevolence. To this end, Paul intro-duces Christ as an example, stating: ÒLet the same mind be in you that was also in Christ Jesus, who, though he was in the form of God, did not regard himself to be equal to God, but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant, made in human likeness, and being found in human vesture . . . became obedient to the point of death.Ó 126Perverters of Apostolic TeachingTo be sure, those who have completely misunderstood the apostolic vocabulary (Òform of God,Ó Òform of a servant,Ó Òvesture,Ó Òhuman likenessÓ) and have transferred it to the divine and human natures [of Christ] have obscured for us this most salutary word of the ApostleÑeven though Paul wanted to say the following. Although Christ was Þlled with Òthe form of GodÓ and abounded in all good thingsÑso that he required no work or suffering in order to be righteous and saved (for he possessed all these things right from the very beginning)Ñnev-ertheless he was not puffed up by these things nor did he raise himself above us and arrogate to himself some kind of power over us, even though he could by rights have done so. But he acted contrary to this: living, working, suffering, and dying just like other humans, and in ÒvestureÓ and action he was nothing other than a human being, as if he lacked all of these things and possessed nothing of GodÕs Òforms.Ó Yet he did all of this for our sake, in order to serve us and in order that all things that he had accomplished in the Òform of a servantÓ might become ours.Let the Christian Be Conformed to ChristAs Christ, their head, was rich and full through his faith, so each and every Christian ought to be content with this Òform of GodÓ obtained through faith, except that (as I have said) this very faith ought to increase until it is made perfect. For this faith is oneÕs life, righteous-ness, and salvation: preserving and making each person acceptable and giving the Christian all things that Christ possesses, as stated above.127 Paul also conÞrms this in Gal. 2[:20] when he says, ÒAnd the life I now live in the ßesh I live by faith in the Son of God.Ó Although individual Christians128 are thereby free from all works, they should nevertheless once again Òhumble themselvesÓ in this freedom, take on Òthe form of a servant,Ó Òbe made in human form and found in human vesture,Ó and serve, help, and do everything for their neighbor, 124 Phil. 2:1-4. This precedes the biblical text on which the original sermon may have been based.125 Latin: regula (rule).126 Phil. 2:5-8, according to the Vulgate.127 See p. 16.128 Singular in the original throughout this paragraph.[ 95 ][ 96 ][ 97 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.29just as they see God has done and does with them through Christ. And they should do this freely, having regard for nothing except divine approval. Christian TrustMoreover, a Christian should think as follows: ÒAlthough I am unworthy and condemned, in Christ my God devotes to my insigniÞcant person, without any merit and by sheer gracious mercy, all the riches of righteousness and salvation, so that I need absolutely nothing else fur-ther except faith, which believes that it is so. Thus, to such a Father as this, who overwhelms me with these his inestimable riches, why should I not freely, joyfully, with a whole heart and willing eagerness do everything that I know is pleasing and acceptable to him? Therefore, I will give myself as a kind of Christ to my neighbor, just as Christ offered himself to me. I will do nothing in this life except what I see will be necessary, advantageous, and salutary for my neighbor, because through faith I am overßowing with all good things in Christ.ÓThe Fruits of Faith (See, My Reader, How Worthily Luther Is Condemned!)Look at what love and joy in the Lord129 ßow from faith! Moreover, from love proceeds a joyful, gladsome, and free soul, prepared for willing service to the neighbor, which takes no account of gratitude or ingratitude, praise or blame, proÞt or loss. For such a soul does not do this so that people may be obligated to it, nor does it distinguish between friends and enemies, nor does it anticipate thankfulness or ingratitude. Instead, it expends itself and what it has in a completely free and happy manner, whether squandering these things on the ungrateful or on the deserving. For as its Father also doesÑdistributing everything to all people abundantly and freely and making Òhis sun to rise on the evil and on the good,Ó130 so the son [or daughter] only does or suffers everything with spontaneous joy, as each person has through Christ been Þlled with delight in God, the lavish dispenser of all things.Recognizing How Great the Things Given to Us AreTherefore, you see that if we recognize those great and precious things that have been given to us, then, as Paul says, Òlove . . . is poured out in our hearts through the . . . Spirit.Ó131 By this love we are free, joyful, all-powerful workers and victors over all tribulations, servants of our neighbors and, nevertheless, still lords of all.132 But for all who do not recognize what has been given to them through Christ, Christ was born in vain, and such people carry on using works, never attaining a taste or sense of the things just described. Therefore, just as our neighbor has need and lacks what we have in abundance, so also we had need before God and lacked GodÕs mercy. For this reason, as our heavenly Father supported us freely in Christ, so also we ought freely to support our neighbor with our body and its actions, and each person ought to become to the other a kind of Christ, so that we may be Christs to one another and be the same Christ in all, that is, truly Christians! The Glory of the Christian LifeTherefore, who can comprehend the riches and glory of the Christian life? It can do all things and has all things and lacks nothing. It is lord of sin, death, and hell but, at the same time, is servant and obedient and beneÞcial to all. And yet how terrible it is that in our day this life is unknown! It is neither preached about nor sought after. 129 See Phil. 4:4.130 Matt. 5:45.131 Rom. 5:5.132 See above, p. 10.[ 98 ][ 99 ][ 100 ][ 101 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.30Why We Are Called ChristiansWhat is more, we are also completely ignorant of our very name, why we are Christians and bear that name. Without a doubt we are named after ChristÑnot absent from us but dwelling in us; in other words: provided that we believe in him and that, in turn and mutually, we are a second Christ to one another, doing for our neighbors as Christ does for us.133 But nowaays, using human doctrines,134 we are taught to seek nothing but merits, rewards, and the things that are ours, and we have made out of Christ nothing but a slave driver far harsher than Moses. 135The Holy Mother of God as an Example of FaithThe blessed Virgin provides a preeminent example of this very faith, when (as is written in Luke 2[:22]) she was puriÞed Òaccording to the Law of Moses,Ó as was the custom of all women. Although she was not bound by such a law and had no need of puriÞcation, nev-ertheless, she subjected herself to the law out of free and voluntary love, doing just as other women did, so that she did not offend or disdain them. She was therefore not justiÞed by this work, but as one already righteous, she did it freely and spontaneously. So also our works ought not be done for the purpose of being justiÞed, sinceÑalready justiÞed by faithÑwe ought to do all things freely and joyfully for the sake of others.Paul Teaches WorksSt. Paul also circumcised his disciple Timothy,136 not because circumcision was necessary for righteousness but rather so that he would not offend or disdain the Jews who were weak in faith and who could not yet grasp faithÕs freedom. However, on the contrary, when in contempt of this freedom of faith they insisted upon circumcision as necessary for righ-teousness, he resisted and did not permit Titus to be circumcised (Gal. 2[:3]). For just as he did not want to offend or disdain any personÕs weakness in faith, yielding to their wishes as appropriate, so also he did not want the freedom of faith to be offended against or dis-dained by hardened Òjustices.Ó He took a middle course, sparing the weak as appropriate and always resisting the hardened, so that he might convert everyone to the freedom of faith. Our actions also ought to be done with the same devotion, so that we support the weak in faith (as Rom. 14[:1] teaches) but resist boldly the hardened ÒmastersÓ of works, about which we will say more below.The Example of Christ the LordMoreover, in Matt. 17[:24-27], when a tax payment was demanded from the disciples, Christ discussed with Peter whether or not a kingÕs sons were exempt from paying taxes. But when Peter afÞrmed that they were exempt, Jesus nevertheless commanded him to go to the sea, saying [v. 27]: ÒHowever, so that we do not give offense to them, go to the sea and cast a hook; take the Þrst Þsh that comes up; and when you open its mouth you will Þnd a coin; take that and give it to them for you and me.Ó This example beautifully supports our argument, in that Christ refers to himself and his own as free sons of the king, who need nothing, and yet he willingly submits and pays the tax. As little as this deed was necessary or useful for righ-teousness or salvation, so all of his other works and those of his followers contribute nothing to righteousness, since all of these things are a result of righteousness and free, done only as an example and a service to others.133 See Matt. 7:12 and John 13:34.134 See Mark 7:7.135 Latin: exactor. 136 Acts 16:3.[ 102 ][ 103 ][ 104 ][ 105 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.31Let All the Religious Understand and Let Luther Be Your Teacher137The same thing goes for what Paul commands in Rom. 13[:1] and Titus 3[:1], saying, ÒLetÓ them Òbe subject to the governing authoritiesÓ and Òbe ready for every good workÓÑnot that they may be justiÞed through this (since they are already justiÞed by faith) but so that through these things and in the freedom of the Spirit they may serve the authorities, among others, and may obey them out of willing, spontaneous love. The works of all clerical institu-tions, monasteries, and priests should be of this kind, too. Thus, each would only do works of his own profession and walk of life, in order to work not toward righteousness but, in the Þrst place, toward the subjection of his own body as an example for the sake of others, who have need to discipline their own bodies, too. In the second place, they would also obey oth-ers and do their bidding out of spontaneous love. Nevertheless, here the utmost care must be taken, so that a false trust does not presume that such works justify, earn reward, or saveÑwhich is all from faith alone, as I have repeatedly said.A True ChristianÕs KnowledgeTherefore, whoever has this knowledge can easily and without danger manage those count-less rules and commands of the pope, bishops, monasteries, churches, princes, and magis-trates. Some foolish shepherds 138 insist that these things are all necessary for righteousness and salvation, calling them Òcommands of the church,Ó although they are nothing of the kind. For a free Christian will say instead, ÒI will fast, pray, and do this or that because it is commanded by human beingsÑnot because this is necessary for righteousness or salvation but because in this behavior I may conduct myself toward the pope, bishop, community, this or that magistrate, or my neighbor as an example. I will do or suffer all things, as Christ often did and suffered many things for meÑnone of which he needed for himself at all, hav-ing been Òplaced under the lawÓ on my account, although he was not under the law.139 And although tyrants may harm or use force [to effect compliance], it will still not do harm, as long as [what they commanded] was not against God.Ó Distinguishing Good Shepherds from Evil OnesFrom all these examples, 140 any person can derive Þrm judgment and reliable distinction among all works and laws and can recognize who are the blind, foolish shepherds and who are the true and good ones. For any work not directed toward the purpose of either disci-plining the body or serving the neighbor (as long as the neighbor demands nothing against God) is neither good nor Christian. As a result, I greatly fear that nowadays few if any clerical institutions, monasteries, high altars, or ecclesiastical ofÞces are Christian, along with spe-cial fasts and prayers for certain saints. To repeat, I fear that in all of these things nothing is sought after except what has to do with us, because we think that through them our sins are cleansed and salvation is attained. In this way, Christian freedom is completely obliterated, because [this attitude] arises from ignorance of Christian faith and freedom.Many completely blind shepherds zealously support such ignorance and suppression of freedom, while at the same time inciting and encouraging the people in their devotion by praising these things and inßating them with indulgences, and yet never teaching faith at all. 137 Latin: religiosi, a technical term encompassing the ordained (priests and bishops) and those under a vow (monks, nuns, and friars).138 Latin: pastores.139 Some modern versions end the quotation here. Quotation marks were not employed in sixteenth-century printings. The reference is to Gal. 4:4-5.140 Literally, Òthings.Ó [ 106 ][ 107 ][ 108 ][ 109 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.32AdviceInstead, I desire each of you to consider that if you really want to pray, fast, or establish a foundation in churches (as they say), pay attention to whether you are doing it for the pur-pose of obtaining some temporal or eternal reward! Be Concerned for Faith AloneYou may harm your faith, which alone offers you all things. For this reason, let faith be your sole concern, so that faith may be increased by exercising it either through works or suffering. Meanwhile, whatever you give, give freely and without reward, so that others may experience increase and reap beneÞts from you and what is yours. For in this way, you will be truly good and Christian. For what are your good works (which function most fully for bodily discipline) to you, when for yourself you are Þlled through your faith, in which God gives you all things? 141The Rule for ÒBrotherly LoveÓLook here! This should be the rule: that the good things we have from God may ßow from one person to the other and become common property. In this way each person may Òput onÓ his [or her] neighbor and conduct oneself toward him [or her] as if in the neighborÕs place. These good things ßowed and ßow into us from Christ, who put us on and acted for us, as if he himself were what we are. They now ßow from us into those who have need of them. Just as my faith and righteousness ought to be placed before God to cover and intercede for the neighborÕs sins, which I take upon myself, so also I labor under and am subject to them as if they were my very own. For this is what Christ did for us. For this is true love and the genuine rule of the Christian life. Now where there is true and genuine faith, there is true and genuine love. Hence, the Apostle in 1 Cor. 13[:5] attributes to love that Òit does not seek its own.Ó 142The Christian Lives in Christ and the NeighborTherefore, we conclude that Christian individuals143 do not live in themselves but in Christ and their neighbor, or else they are not Christian. They live in Christ through faith and in the neighbor through love. Through faith they are caught up beyond themselves into God; likewise through love they fall down beneath themselves into the neighborÑremaining nev-ertheless always in God and GodÕs love, as Christ says in John 1[:51]: ÒVery truly I say to you, you will see the heavens opened and the angels of God ascending and descending upon the Son of Man.ÓLet this sufÞce concerning that freedom, which, as you see, is spiritual and true, making our hearts free from all sin, laws, and commands, as Paul says in 1 Tim. 1[:9], ÒThe law is not laid down for the righteous person.Ó 144 This freedom is far above all other external freedoms, as high as heaven is above the earth. May Christ cause us to know and preserve this freedom! Amen.141 Luther uses the word you (singular: tu) Þve times in this sentence, including pro te (Òfor youÓ).142 Following here the more literal Latin Vulgate.143 This is singular in the original throughout this paragraph.144 A literal rendering of the Latin Vulgate and the Greek text.[ 111 ][ 112 ][ 113 ][ 114 ][ 110 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.33[Appendix] Against the Freedom of the Flesh145Finally, this must be added because of those for whom nothing can be stated well enough that they cannot distort it by warped understandingÑif they could even understand what is said here at all. There are so many people who, when they hear about this freedom of faith, immediately turn it into Òan occasion for the ßesh.Ó 146 They imagine that straightaway all things are permitted for them, and they want to be free and seem Christian in no other way than by showing contempt and disdain for ceremonies,147 traditions, and human laws. As if they were Christians precisely because they do not fast on the stated days or because they themselves eat meat while others fast or they refrain from saying the customary prayers! They stick up their noses, make fun of human commands, and hold the other things that in fact pertain to the Christian religion in low esteem. Against Trust in WorksThese people are stubbornly resisted by those who strive for salvation solely by reverent observance of ceremoniesÑas if they might be saved because they fast on the appointed days or abstain from meat or pray certain prayers. They boast about the precepts of the church and the Fathers while not caring one wit about those things that concern our genuine faith. Both sides are plainly in error, because they are so confused and troubled about unnecessary and silly things while neglecting the more serious things that are necessary for salvation.How much more correct is the Apostle Paul, who teaches taking the middle way and condemns both sides completely when he says, ÒThose who eat must not despise those who abstain, and those who abstain must not pass judgment on those who eat.Ó 148 You see here that those who neglect or despise ceremoniesÑnot out of a sense of piety but rather out of sheer contemptÑare upbraided, since Paul teaches not to condemn, for Òknowledge puffs them up.Ó 149 On the other hand, he teaches those other, obstinate people not to judge the former group. For neither side cares about the Òlove that builds upÓ the neighbor.150 There-fore, Scripture must be listened to, which teaches that we Òwill turn aside neither to the right nor to the leftÓ 151 but will follow Òthe acceptable righteousness of the Lord that gladdens the heart.Ó 152 For just as no one is righteous by preserving or being a slave to the works and rites of ceremonies, so also no one is deemed righteous by simply omitting and condemning them.For we are not free from works through faith in Christ but from conjectures about works, that is, from the foolish presumption of justiÞcation acquired through works. For faith redeems, makes right, and guards our consciences, so that we realize that righteousness is not in worksÑalthough works can and should not be lacking. For example, we cannot exist without food and drink and all the other works of this mortal body, and yet our righteous-ness is not built upon them but upon faith. Still these things must not be condemned or omitted. Thus, in this world we are bound by the necessities of this bodily life, but we are not righteous because of them. Christ said, ÒMy kingdom is not from this world . . . not from here,Ó but he did not say, ÒMy kingdom is not here in this world.Ó 153 Paul also says, ÒFor 145 ÒAgainst the Freedom of the FleshÓ is from the 2nd ed. 146 Gal. 5:13 according to the Vulgate and Greek text. NRSV: Òan opportunity for self-indulgence.Ó147 Throughout this section and above on p. 13, Luther uses the word ceremonies for all types of religious rules and regulations, not just for liturgical rites.148 Rom. 14:3.149 Paraphrasing 1 Cor. 8:1.150 Paraphrasing 1 Cor. 8:1.151 Paraphrasing Deut. 2:27 and 28:14.152 Paraphrasing Ps. 19:8.153 John 18:36.[ 115 ][ 116 ][ 117 ][ 118 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.34though we walk in the ßesh, we do not war according to the ßesh.Ó 154 And in Gal. 2[:20] he says, ÒThe life I now live in the ßesh I live by faith in the Son of God.Ó Thus, the necessities of life and the need to control the body cause us to act and live and exist with works and ceremonies. Nevertheless, we are righteous not through these things but through faith in the Son of God. For this reason, the same middle way is set out for each Christian, who must also keep in mind these two types of people. How to Deal with the StubbornOn the one hand, the Christian encounters the stubborn and obstinate ceremonialists. Like deaf adders,155 they do not want to hear freedomÕs truth, but instead they boast about their ceremonies as the means of justiÞcation, imperiously commanding and insisting on them quite apart from faith. The Jews of old, who did not want to understand anything about how to behave properly, were like this. Against these people one ought to resist, do the opposite, and boldly offend them, so that they do not mislead many others as well by this ungodly opinion. In their presence it is appropriate to eat meat, to break fasts, and for the freedom of faith to do other things that they take for the greatest of sins. It must be said of them, ÒLet them alone; they are blind guides of the blind.Ó156 In line with this, Paul did not want Titus to be circumcised when some demanded it,157 and Christ defended the apostles because they wanted [to pluck] grain on the Sabbath and in many other instances.158Regarding the Common FolkOn the other hand, the Christian encounters the simple, uneducated, ignorant, and (as Paul calls them) weak in faith, who cannot yet understand this freedom of faith, even if they want to. Care must be taken not to offend these people but to defer to their weakness until they are more fully instructed. For fasts and other things that they think are necessary must be kept to avoid causing them to fallÑnot because their actions or thoughts are motivated by deep-seated wickedness but only because they are weak in faith. For love, which seeks to harm no one but only to serve all, demands it. After all, they are weak not by their own fault but by that of their shepherds, who have taken them captive and wickedly beaten them using the snares and rods of their traditions, from which they should have been freed and healed with the teaching of faith and freedom! As the Apostle teaches in [1 Cor. 8:13],159 ÒI will never eat meat, so that I may not cause one of them to fall.Ó And he says elsewhere, ÒI know and am per-suaded by the Lord Jesus that nothing is unclean . . . but to anyone who thinks it is unclean it is unclean . . . [and] it is evil for that person who eats to give offense.Ó160 Concerning Laws and the LawgiversTherefore, although those master teachers of traditions must be boldly resisted and the papal laws, by which they plunder GodÕs people, must be sharply criticized, nevertheless one must refrain from injuring the frightened massesÑwhich those ungodly tyrants hold captive with these very lawsÑuntil they may be set free from them. Thus, Þght vigorously against the wolves but for the sheep and not, in the same breath, against the sheep. Each of you may do this by inveighing against the laws and the lawgivers while at the same time guarding the weak from being offended, until they themselves recognize this tyranny and understand 154 2 Cor. 10:3, using the more literal rendering of the Greek, which matches the Latin Vulgate.155 Ps. 58:4 (see also Mic. 7:16-17).156 Matt. 15:14.157 Gal. 2:3.158 Matt. 12:1-8.159 The original text refers to Romans 14, the passage Luther cites next.160 Rom. 14:14, 20, where Luther cites the Vulgate, which provides a more literal rendering of the Greek.[ 119 ][ 120 ][ 121 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.35their own freedom. If you desire to exercise your freedom, do it in secret, as Paul says in Rom. 14[:22], ÒThe faith that you have, have for yourself before God.Ó 161 But be careful not to exer-cise [faithÕs freedom] before the weak. Contrariwise, before tyrants and stubborn people you may exercise that freedom with contempt and without ever letting up at all. Then they, too, will understand that they are ungodly, that their laws contribute nothing to righteousness, and that, frankly, they did not even have the right to enact them.For the Young and UntrainedThus, it is clear that in this life one cannot live without ceremonies and works. Indeed, hot-headed and untrained adolescents need to be held back and guarded by such restraints. Moreover, individual Christians must discipline their bodies with such efforts. The servant of Christ162 must be wise and faithful, so that he may so rule and teach ChristÕs people about all these things, so that their conscience and faith are not offended. Otherwise, an opinion or Òroot of bitternessÓ may arise in them Òand through it many become deÞled,Ó as Paul warns in Heb. [12:15]. That is to say, Òso that, in the absence of faith, they begin to be deÞled by the opinion about works, as if they were justiÞed through them.Ó This happens quite easily and deÞles many people. Unless faith is constantly inculcated at the same time, it is impossible to avoid the situation where (faith having been silenced) human regulations alone are taught. This has happened today through the pestilent, ungodly, soul-destroying, traditions of our popes and the opinions of our theologians. With an inÞnite number of souls being dragged to hell by these snares, you can recognize Antichrist.Danger in CeremoniesIn conclusion, just as riches endanger poverty; business dealings, honesty; honors, humil-ity; banquets, abstinence; or pleasures, chastity; so also ceremonies endanger the righ-teousness of faith. Solomon asks, ÒCan Þre be carried in the bosom without burning oneÕs clothes?Ó 163 And yet, as with riches, business dealings, honors, pleasures, and feasts, so also one must take part in ceremoniesÑthat is, in dangers. To say this as strongly as pos-sible:164 Just as infant boys need to be attentively caressed at a young womanÕs bosom, in order that they may not perish (even though as adults it endangers salvation for them to be consorting with young women), so also hotheaded, untrained youth need to be restrained and disciplined by the iron bars of ceremonies, so that their unrestrained heart may not go blindly into corruption. And yet it would be the death of them if they insisted on imagin-ing that justiÞcation came from them. Instead, they should be taught that they have been imprisoned in this way not to be righteous or to merit something but so that they would be kept from evil and might more easily be instructed in the righteousness of faith. For, unless their impulsiveness be put in check, they would not put up with such instruction.The Place for CeremoniesThus, ceremonies are to have the same place in the Christian life as a builderÕs construction plans or an artisanÕs instructions. They are not prepared to be the substance and lasting part of a building but because without them nothing can be built or made. For they are set aside once the structure is Þnished. Here you can see that they are not being despised but rather are especially required. What is being despised is a [false] opinion about them: because no 161 Following LutherÕs citation of the Vulgate, which renders the Greek more literally.162 Latin: minister Christi, LutherÕs favorite designation for the public minister.163 Prov. 6:27.164 Latin: immo, an adversative much beloved by Luther, who used it to introduce radical or even contrary ideas from what had just been stated. It is similar to the archaic ÒforsoothÓ or Ònay, verily.Ó[ 122 ][ 123 ][ 124 ]
From: The Freedom of a Christian 1520: The Annotated Luther Study Edition, translated by Timothy J. Wengert, copyright © 2016 Fortress Press. Posted by permission. No further reproduction allowed without the written permission of Fortress Press. May be reproduced for local, non-commercial use in ELCA congregations and worshiping communities through December 31, 2020, provided this copyright notice is included on each copy. Please direct all other requests for reproduction to copyright@1517.media.36one imagines that plans are the real and permanent structure. Who would be so silly that they would care for nothing in life other than plans that they had most lavishly, carefully, and stubbornly 165 prepared while never thinking about the structure itself and only being pleased with and boasting about their work in making plans and such vain Þrst steps? Would not everybody have pity on such insanity and judge that something great could have been built by this wasted expense? In the same way, we do not despise ceremonies or works but rather especially require them. However, we despise the [false] opinion about works, so that a person may not imagine that they are true righteousness, as hypocrites do. They waste their whole life by tying their life to works, and yet they never arrive at the goal for which works are done. As the Apostle says, they Òare always being instructed and can never arrive at nowledge of the truth.Ó 166 For it seems that they want to build and to prepare themselves and yet never actually build anything. So they remain with Òthe outward form of godliness and do notÓ attain Òits power.Ó 167On Hyper-Religious 168 PeopleAll the while these people are pleased with their efforts and dare to judge everyone else whom they do not see glowing with a similar display of works. Instead, had they been Þlled with faith, by properly using GodÕs gifts (rather than vainly wasting and abusing them) they could have brought about great things for their salvation and the salvation of others. But human nature and natural reason (as they call it) are naturally hyper-religious and, whenever some laws and works are proposed, promptly jump to the conclusion that justiÞcation may be attained through them. Added to this, reason is trained and strengthened in this very point of view by the practice of all earthly lawgivers. Therefore, it is impossible that by its own pow-ers [reason] may free itself from servitude to this view of works and come into the necessary knowledge of faithÕs freedom. For this reason, prayer is needed, so that the Lord may Òdraw usÓ and make us Òtheodidaktos,Ó that is, Òtaught by God.Ó 169 Moreover, as he promised, he will Òwrite the law in our hearts.Ó 170 Otherwise, it is all over for us. For unless God teaches this wisdom hidden in mystery 171 inwardly, [human] nature, because it is offended and regards it as foolish, can only condemn it and judge it to be heretical.172 What we observe happened to the prophets and Apostles, those godless and blind pontiffs and their ßatterers are now doing to me and people like me. In the end, Òmay God be merciful to us . . . and cause his face to shine upon us, so that we may know his way on earth, among all nations the saving power of the oneÓ 173 who is blessed forever. Amen.165 Latin: pertinacissime. In this context, Luther means Òmeticulously,Ó but he is using the same word that he had already used to describe Òstubborn ceremonialists.Ó166 2 Tim. 3:7.167 2 Tim. 3:5.168 Here and below superstitiosus (here translated Òhyper-religiousÓ)means Þxed on oneÕs own unreasonable ideas about religion.169 Luther is quoting John 6:44-45, mixing the Latin and Greek text.170 Jer. 31:33.171 See Col. 1:26.172 See 1 Cor. 1:23.173 A close paraphrase of Ps. 67:1-2.[ 125 ]
